October 2026

Aman Tokyo or Four Seasons Otemachi? Choosing between Tokyo's two palace-view towers

On most trips I'd pick the Four Seasons at Otemachi over Aman Tokyo, its neighbour a few minutes' walk away above the same Imperial Palace gardens. The Aman has the most beautiful room and bath in Tokyo. The Four Seasons wins nearly everything else, from the bed to the bar, for about half the price.

Aman TokyoFour Seasons Tokyo at Otemachi
The buildingTop six floors of Otemachi Tower, 84 suites, opened 2014Top floors of Otemachi One Tower, about 190 rooms, opened 2020
The lobby33rd floor, under a washi-paper ceiling nearly 30 metres high39th floor, with a long reflecting pool under a domed cupola
Smallest room71 square metresAbout 50 square metres
The bathDeep stone furo against the window in every suiteFreestanding tub, by the window in many palace-side rooms
Pool30 metres, black basalt, the city right beside you20 metres, black-tiled lap pool, swim caps required
Food and drinkMusashi sushi counter and Arva, good but not memorableest, Pigneto and Virtù, one of Asia's 50 Best Bars
A typical nightAbout $2,000, nearer $3,000 for a Garden View SuiteAbout $1,050
Best forTwo nights in the most beautiful room in TokyoAlmost any trip, three or four nights
Our score7.9 out of 108.3 out of 10

Two towers, one view

The first morning at the Four Seasons the curtains opened by themselves on Mount Fuji, white-capped behind the Shinjuku towers, and I actually yelled. Aman Tokyo looks out at the same view from about 300 metres away, and whether to book it or the Four Seasons at Otemachi is the Tokyo question I get asked most.

Short version… the Aman has the better room, and the Four Seasons has the better everything else.

The rooms

I don't think any hotel room in Tokyo beats the Aman's. Even the smallest suite is 71 square metres, all pale wood and sliding washi screens with a long window seat across the glass, and our welcome strawberries were so fragrant I could smell them from the door.

The Four Seasons rooms start at about 50 square metres, calm and warm with gold and lapis-blue touches and a chaise by the window. I liked ours a lot, but it's a step down.

The bed goes the other way. The Aman's felt like two twins pushed together, and the Four Seasons bed was one of the best of my whole trip. A few things at the Aman feel cheap for the money, too (a hollow minibar door, a plastic cover on the room-service plate).

The bath

Every Aman suite has a deep stone furo right against the window, with cypress salts that smell woody and wonderful and a little card that walks you through the Japanese bathing ritual. I followed it every night, with the whole city lit up below the glass.

The Four Seasons tub is deep and freestanding, often by the window in the palace-side rooms, with hinoki salts made for the hotel. If it weren't 300 metres from the Aman's, I'd be raving about it.

Arriving

The Aman's lift opens on the 33rd floor under a washi-paper ceiling nearly 30 metres high, with a still pool, two little rock gardens and a huge seasonal ikebana. You check in sitting down, with green tea and a cold towel. I've walked into a lot of lobbies and never stopped dead in one like that.

The Four Seasons lobby on the 39th floor, a long shallow pool under a domed cupola, is warmer and more classic. It's busier, though, and with cars pulling up one after another, check-in got a little brisk.

Eating and drinking

The Four Seasons is the better place to eat and drink, by a distance. Virtù is one of the best bars in Asia, moody and Parisian over the city lights, and I had a Smoked Ume Fashioned there EVERY night. est, the ten-course Japanese-French dinner, is the one to dress up for.

At the Aman everything was beautifully plated, but I couldn't tell you much about it now. The exception is Musashi, the sushi counter, where the chef grows his own rice and makes the ceramics you eat from. Book it before you arrive, wherever you're sleeping.

Breakfast is closer. The Aman's is slow (allow 40 minutes, and order the Japanese set). On a quiet morning the Four Seasons does one of the best in Tokyo, custard French toast with Fuji at the end of the view, but by 8:30 there's a line out the door, so go early.

Pool and spa

The Aman pool is the prettier one, 30 metres of black basalt beside a wall of glass, with the city glowing right next to you after dark. Its spa is the biggest of any hotel in Tokyo, with hot Japanese baths in the changing rooms.

The Four Seasons has a 20-metre lap pool where swim caps are compulsory, so no floating about with a book (and I REALLY wanted to). Its Yakusugi Forest Renewal, with cypress from Yakushima, smelled like a forest after rain, though, so I'd call the spas a draw.

Service

The Aman's goodbye is the best I've had in Tokyo. The house car took us to the station, and someone walked us right to our seats on the bullet train. But I got stopped at the entrance when I was plainly a guest, and one night at Arva they started closing up around us.

The Four Seasons felt warmer from start to finish. They knew our names on day one, and a birthday mentioned in the booking meant a bouquet at check-in and a cake in the room. One of the front desk team even rang a ski resort in Karuizawa for us, in Japanese, when we were stuck.

The price

For most people, this is what settles it. The Aman usually costs about twice as much for the same view, and in cherry-blossom season and over New Year the gap gets wider.

And the Garden View Suite, the one I'd actually want there, costs more again.

Which one I'd book

So for most trips, it's the Four Seasons, three or four nights in a palace-side Deluxe room, or a corner Premier room if you want more space. That's what I tell first-timers, couples and anyone planning bullet-train day trips.

The Aman is for a big occasion, when the room is the point. Book two nights in the Garden View Suite, take a bath every night, eat once at Musashi and go out into the city for every other meal.

Better still, split the trip… two nights at the Aman, then walk down the road to the Four Seasons for whatever's left.

Want more buzz? The Bulgari Hotel Tokyo by Tokyo Station is the fun one, and the Palace Hotel Tokyo looks over the same gardens for a good deal less than either. You'll find the rest of Tokyo on my Japan page.